A Book Review of Dixie Walker of the Dodgers - The People's Choice Written by Maury Allen

Maury Allen wrote the biography of a majoropposing player during spring training in 1947,
league ballplayer with deep roots back to hisexpecting the big league club to see his skill level
southern heritage. Dixie Walker became a fanand demand that he join the roster. This did not
favorite through his play on the field, but carrieswork of course, a petition was generated, and
the legacy of having been an opponent to theWalker sent a letter to Branch Rickey indicating
breaking of the color barrier in baseball. In histhat he wanted to be traded. Maury points out
book titled Dixie Walker of the Dodgers: Thethat the letter never specifically stated that the
People's Choice, Maury Allen reviews this dualrequest was because he did not want to play
legacy.with Robinson, but that he felt he had become a
When the Brooklyn Dodgers, and specificallyfocal point in the controversy and a "scapegoat"
Branch Rickey, decided to have Jackie Robinsonfor all of the southern players in opposition.
on the roster for the 1947 season, it was said toWalker went on to play during the 1947 season
have been Walker who generated a petition toand apparently the on the field results were
team management in opposition of the move.enough to help overcome any of the tension that
Seasons prior to the fateful events of springhad existed during spring training. Winning (and
training in 1947, Walker had been dubbed as themoney) helped soothe many of the challenges
successor to Babe Ruth in the Yankees lineup butthat stood in the way of Jackie Robinson's
injuries and the arrival of a kid named Joeteammates.
DiMaggio made him expendable. AfterMaury had a chance to get to know Dixie Walker
accumulating decent career numbers with theyears later while Walker was coaching. The
White Sox and Tigers, he was picked up by thecommon response to any inquiries into the
Brooklyn Dodgers for the 1940 season. With thesituation was that in those times it was a natural
Dodgers he not only continued to hit the baseball,response to an attempt at integration, but after
but most importantly to fans, he always camegetting to know Jackie he learned to respect him,
through when it counted against the rival Newthough they never became close friends. Walker
York Giants!also indicated that Robinson was not an easy
As things can happen in baseball and in life, thingsperson to get to like no matter his race,
are not always what the might seem at first.competitiveness and personality had an impact on
According to this article written by Jack Cuddya real friendship.
and carried here by the Modesto Bee, thingsDixie Walker had a good season in 1947, but the
were looking up for Dixie Walker with a change atDodgers still decided to trade him to Pittsburgh
the top of the Dodgers from Larry McPhail toprior to 1948. Speculation was always that he
Branch Rickey. According to Maury, McPhail waswas traded because of the opposition to
the "George Steinbrenner of his day" and had aRobinson, however as Maury discovered by
lot of conflicts with Dixie because of the adulationspeaking with Ralph Branca years later, it was
the fans and the media heaped upon him. Afterpurely a baseball business decision. Walker was
the put downs and struggles with McPhail, thingsgetting up there in years and was traded as a 37
had to look better with new management. It wasyear old ballplayer in the twilight of a career. In
of course the efforts that Rickey made towardsfact, he was finished in the majors just two
integration that would ultimately connect Walkeryears later. As Rickey always said "it's better to
and Robinson in the conflict that defined Walker'strade a player a year too soon than a year too
legacy.late".
It takes some effort to put these historicalMaury worked with Susan Walker, Dixie's
situations in context from our current culturaldaughter, when writing this book. She had no
point of view, but during Walker's playing career itknowledge of her father's career directly, but
was The Negro Leagues where Africancould only infer from the comments from the
Americans played the game, with a "separate butnumerous inquirers who knew of Walker's
equal" type of mindset. Rickey was motivated forreputation as the guy who tried to block Jackie
a number of reasons to integrate the game,Robinson. Readers will get a great background on
including experiences with a former teammate,the family aspects of Walker's story, including his
stocking the farm system with high caliberwife Estelle who worked for Sonny Werblin
players, and financial reward at the gate.seeking out talent for the MCA radio show Your
Walker's perspective was of course veryHit Parade.
different, with pressures from business associatesMaury Allen is able to identify the changing culture
in his Alabama hometown of Birmingham, as wellthat was taking place in the country during this
as a general sense throughout baseball that jobstime period, and how it was impacting the game
were at stake. Players on the margins had to beof baseball. It is a significant story that we do not
looking over their shoulders at this potential influxusually get to hear.
of quality ballplayers and wanted to make everyYou can find Maury at The to keep up with his
effort to save their own positions.current writings, and we look forward to any
Maury recalls a failed strategy that Rickey used inother books that he delivers in the future.
his integration attempts, using Robinson as an